🎥 Every Hotel Buy Now Instant Access→

Is All-Star Music Worth It? Honest Review


Watch All Star Music vs Hilton Orlando Lake Buena Video


For my dates, yes. All-Star Music came to $249 a night all-in for a family of four: $199 for the room, $50 for breakfast at the food court, no resort fee and no parking fee. Hilton Orlando Lake Buena Vista looked about the same price on the booking page. Once I added the $92 breakfast buffet, the $41 resort fee and $38 parking, it came to $322 a night.


The booking page can't tell you how each one feels.


Walk into All-Star Music and it's all colors, murals and music. It's a great Disney feeling. Walk into the Hilton and it's a corporate hotel. It has some theming, just not that overwhelming Disney feel.


The rooms are closer than you'd think. Both have a coffee maker, and neither has a microwave. I hate that, because I like to heat up my coffee or a piece of pizza. All-Star Music has a chiller instead of a real fridge (mine read 41 degrees) and an extra bed that pulls down. The Hilton room is small and older, but the furniture is really nice and the fridge is a decent size.


At All-Star Music you walk out to the Disney buses. I'm not a huge bus fan, but they worked for me on this trip. Here's what time Disney buses start running. The Hilton shuttle has to be reserved with a QR code at the front desk, and it leaves every hour starting at 6:30AM. Both hotels get early entry at Magic Kingdom, so that isn't the tiebreaker.


The Hilton's big win is location. There's a shortcut from the pool area, and I was at Disney Springs in less than five minutes. Here's my full Hilton Orlando Lake Buena Vista review.


The honest catch: prices move with your dates. This time the Hilton cost more. Next time it could flip. Add up breakfast, the resort fee and parking before you decide.


So is All-Star Music worth it? If your family wants the Disney feeling and the (sometimes) lowest total, yes. If walking to Disney Springs matters most, the Hilton earns its price.


Right hotel, right people, right price.


More on-property answers: Every Disney Hotel Question Answered


One more thing before you book

The booking page shows you the room. It doesn't show the fees, the walk or how the place feels. I've filmed full walkthroughs of both hotels, so you can see each one before you book.


Free Disney Hotels Hidden Fees Guide



Stop guessing. Don't book the wrong hotel. 


dDadbudget.com